My friends
Honest Abe and
Jim Purcell are beginning to go off on "dirty money" from developers and "Pay to Play" over at Abe's blog. This is an issue where I disagree with Abe and Jim.
I'm concerned that as a party we are over reacting to past scandals and that we are letting the
Asbury Park Press set our fund raising policies. When the APP starts making as much an issue of Labor Union contributions as they have with vendor and developer contributions, they will have more credibility with me.
Rather than re-invent the wheeling, I give you the words of another friend, former Freeholder candidate
Tom DeSeno, as originally published in his
Justified Right column in the
TriCity News on February 15, 2006. (Note to Tom and Dan: Please don't sue me for copyright infringement. Consider this a plug to increase your readership among the surburbanites. Then again, if you do sue me, maybe the APP will cover us and we'll all get more readers. Hmmmm.)
PAY TO PLAY: A phony scare like the Jersey Devil.
An open challenge to debate Heather TaylorBy Tommy DeSeno. Originally published in the TriCity News. February 15,2006Who cannot open an honest mind / no friend will he be of mine. Euripides
Like the only boy honest enough in the Kingdom to yell, "The Emperor has no clothes," I stand now to yell: "The pay-to-play problem is a fake media illusion to scare people, just like the Jersey Devil."
Before we get into it, let's clarify some law: Each of us has a 1st amendment right of "free speech" to endorse a candidate for office. The right to donate money to a candidate has been held as "free speech." By law if I want to stand on a street corner and yell, "Vote for George," since I have a 1st Amendment right to do so, a town will need a "compelling" state interest to stop my speech. Well by the very same laws, a town will need to show a "compelling" state interest to stop me from writing a check to George.
Here is the usual media dupe on pay-to-play: An engineer likes a candidate for City Council and donates $2,600.00 to him. Candidate wins. The next month that same engineer is hired by the city as an engineer.
Now here is the media "assumption:" All people in the world being corrupt, criminal, base, vile, awful and bad, the engineer over-bills the City to get his $2,600.00 back and the city raises taxes to cover it, so the taxpayers lose money.
"Oh what a terrible scandal!" yelled the mainstream media. "Let's write a billion words on it and convince New Jerseyeans that every local politician (also known as their friends and neighbors) is corrupt and every professional in the world is a hell-bound sinner!" So the media assault began, and it never stopped.
Here's the real deal: The assumption above isn't true. Professionals, despite contributing to campaigns, don't over-bill their government clients. If you poll lawyers with government contracts, most charge about 50% less per hour to the government than they do to their private clients.
The media response is: "Who gives a damn about the truth. We have the greatest "scare" story since War of the Worlds. Let's keep writing it!"
There is a group running amok in New Jersey pressuring every town and county to pass their version of Pay to Play laws (and many towns are caving in faster than a trailer park in a tornado). The group is called Center for Civic Responsibility and it is connected to the national group called Commie Cause. I mean Common Cause. Sorry. Scampering about the state for them, Jersey Devil in tow, is Heather Taylor.
When the Asbury Park Press writes about this group, they refer to them as "the good government group." OK AP Press, a lesson in journalism: Objectivity does not allow for value judgments when describing a partisan group, so when you... Oh forget it. Look who I'm talking to.
So Heather skips from town to town with her cookie-cutter pay-to-pay laws and says, "We insist you pass this law." Then she winks. Do you know what the wink means? "If you don"t pass it, the Asbury Park Press will grind you into sausage meat." Fearing for the good reputations of their families because there is no way to fight the AP Press, towns dutifully pass Heather's laws.
Here is my proof that Heather's group and the Asbury Park Press are over-stuffed like 10 pounds of manure in a 5 pound bag. Consider the firm Schoor DePalma, a group of engineers hired by government all over New Jersey. So as to remove themselves from this silliness, they announced they will no longer give any campaign contributions. You know what they didn't announce? That they were lowering their fees! You see, despite formerly being large campaign contributors, they weren't over-billing government to get the money back, and government wasn't raising taxes to pay them back. There was no "hidden tax." Schoor De Palma was hired then, and now, because they are great engineers.
That is also proof of my main assertion: Even if every town in New Jersey passes Heather's pay to play law, not one town will have their budget reduced by even a penny. She is selling a phony, made-up, non-existent scandal and a "feel-good" law to fix it.
All Heather and the Jersey Devil Press are accomplishing is to take away campaign dollars. The problem is, not all money is bad. Much off it is good. People have busy lives, so the only way they get to know who candidates are and what they stand for is advertising, which costs money. Without ads, the electorate will be uninformed. By the way, did the Asbury Park Press offer to lower their advertising rates to political campaigns to help the electorate stay informed? Of course not; they're no Schoor De Palma.
Now take me for example. My firm has an appointment in non-partisan Asbury Park. Heather's group demanded Asbury pass a pay to play law that says not only can't I give money in Asbury, but I can't give to the County Republican Party, which by the way spends exactly $0.00 each year in Asbury Park. So as a Monmouth County resident, I can't buy a $45.00 ticket to a Monmouth fundraiser to buy flyers that let people know about our candidates. Under these same laws though, Camden County boys George Norcross and Joe Roberts donated $1 million dollars in Monmouth last year to lie about our people. Heather and the Asbury Park Press call that "good government." Good Grief. By the way, The AP Press is "coincidentally" run by 2 Camden men. Double Good Grief.
Right now the good people in Tinton Falls are acting to remove the very unconstitutional ban on Contributions to County Parties from their pay-to-pay law. Applause! They should also get rid of the "large firm loophole" that allows big firms to donate but not small firms (what big firms made donations to Heather's group to ensure that was in there?).
So today I challenge Heather to debate me on these subjects, and I'll do it in front of the editorial board of the Asbury Park Press so she can feel at home. Any time.